Pisa Bite Club's Most Loved Pizzas of 2025

After thousands of member reviews and ratings, Pisa Bite Club presents the community-voted most loved pizzas of 2025. These aren't critic picks. They're what real pizza eaters chose to return to again and again.

One. Community Gold: Neapolitan Margherita at Local Independent Shops
The most reviewed and highest-rated category across all communities. A perfectly executed Margherita at a locally owned Neapolitan spot beat every corporate and celebrity chef competitor.

Two. Reader's Choice: Detroit-Style Pan Pizza
Detroit-style dominated the regional category. Its crispy caramelized cheese edges, square shape, and thick airy interior won over enormous numbers of new converts this year.

Three. Best Discovery: Smash-Style Pizza
Inspired by smash burgers, smash pizza flattens dough on a ripping hot griddle for maximum caramelization on both surfaces. Our community called it the most exciting new technique of the year.

Four. Most Craved: Spicy Honey Pepperoni
Classic pepperoni elevated by local honey and fresh chili. The sweet-heat combination proved universally appealing and appeared at more restaurants than any other single flavor combination this year.

Five. Comfort Champion: Mac and Cheese Pizza
Divisive among purists but beloved by the community. Macaroni and cheese as a pizza topping sounds wrong but delivers deeply satisfying comfort food energy. Children and adults voted it a top pick.

Six. Underdog Winner: Clam Casino Pizza
Few dishes are more regional than New England clam pizza. Our community discovery of this briny, garlicky, and utterly unique pizza style earned it a devoted following among members willing to seek it out.